🔥 Events 2026: Plan B, Relocation & Tax Workshops. Book now →

22 Nov 2026
7 min read

Read the Transitional Clause First: How Countries Treat People Who Moved Under the Old Rules

A smiling family of three sits on a wooden jetty on a calm mountain lake in early morning light.

Every change to a tax or residence rule contains two rules. The first is the new rule itself: a higher charge, a stricter test, a new tax. That is the part that makes the news. The second is the rule about who the new rule applies to, and from when. It usually sits at the end of the text, under a heading like "transitional provisions" or "entry into force", and it is rarely reported.

For people who live across borders, the second rule often matters more than the first. A person deciding whether to move somewhere can read the new rule and decide. A person who already moved, sold a house, enrolled children in school and built a life around the old rule cannot decide again on the same terms. Whether the state protects that reliance, ignores it, or reaches back into it is written in the transitional clause.

The argument here is that the transitional clause is the closest thing to a promise a state makes to people who have already come, and that it is the most informative line in any rule change. Recent texts from four countries show four different answers.

Answer one: the new rule is for newcomers

Italy's new-resident regime lets a person who moves to Italy pay a fixed annual amount in place of Italian tax on foreign income. In its budget law for 2026, Law 199 of 30 December 2025, Parliament raised that amount from €200,000 to €300,000, and the amount for each family member from €25,000 to €50,000.

The next paragraph of the same law says who pays the new amount: persons who transfer their residence to Italy from the date the law enters into force. Those who had already moved under the old amount are not mentioned, and keep it.

Thailand made the same choice in a different field. In 2023 the Revenue Department reinterpreted the rule on foreign income brought into the country, so that a resident is taxed on foreign income whenever it is remitted, not only when it is remitted in the year it was earned. A second order, Por.162, limited the change in time. According to the Department's own questions and answers, the new treatment covers foreign income arising from 1 January 2024 for a person present in Thailand 180 days or more in that year. Income that arose before 2024 is not included, even if it is brought into Thailand later.

Both clauses draw a line in time and leave everything behind it alone. A person who moved to Italy in 2025 knows the price of the regime. A person who saved abroad before 2024 knows those savings can be brought into Thailand untaxed, as long as they can show when the money was earned. The Thailand country guide explains the remittance rule as it now works.

This is the generous answer, and it is not an accident. Both countries are competing for the people they are regulating. A regime that changes the terms for people already inside it is a regime nobody will trust next time.

Answer two: the new rule reaches into pending decisions

On 1 October 2026 Japan's Immigration Services Agency revised its guidelines for permanent residence permission, adding requirements on income, on not becoming a burden on public funds and on other points. The Brief described the new fees and requirements at the end of October.

The transitional section is more nuanced than a simple start date. The revised guidelines as a whole apply to applications filed from 1 April 2027, a long lead time that gives applicants six months to prepare. But two provisions, on income and on not becoming a public burden, also apply to applications filed in the six months before the revision and still pending on 1 October 2026.

So a person who applied in, say, June 2026, under the guidelines then in force, and who was still waiting for a decision in October, is assessed in part under rules that did not exist when the application went in. The applicant did nothing differently. The rule moved while the file sat on a desk.

There is a plausible reason for this: the two provisions concern whether an applicant earns enough and would not become a burden on public funds, and a cut-off at the filing date would have rewarded a rush of applications designed to beat the new test. But the effect is that an application, once filed, is not a fixed position. The relevant date is the decision, not the filing.

Answer three: the rule fixes its own date before it exists

Italy's 2027 budget bill, presented to the Chamber of Deputies on 30 October 2026 and now in committee as A.C. 3174-bis, includes a proposed exit tax. Under Article 17 of the bill, a long-term resident who transfers tax residence abroad would be taxed on the unrealised gains on financial assets, valued on the last day of the tax period before the one in which residence is lost.

The clause on entry into force says the charge applies to persons whose loss of Italian residence takes effect from 1 January 2027. On paper that is prospective: nobody who has already left is touched.

In practice the date does more. Italian tax residence is assessed for the tax year, so a person resident in Italy for 2026 cannot, after reading the bill on 30 October, arrange to be non-resident for 2026. The first year in which anyone could leave is the first year the tax applies, and the valuation date for that year is 31 December 2026, around the time Parliament is expected to finish its vote. And the gain that is taxed is the whole gain since purchase, not the gain accrued after the law was announced. A share bought in 2012 would be taxed on fourteen years of growth that took place when no such tax existed.

The logic is easy to see: a tax on leaving that left a window open between announcement and start would cause the very departures it is meant to tax. But it shows that "prospective" can mean different things. The trigger is in the future. The base reaches back.

Answer four: no transition at all

Costa Rica's bill 25.796, filed by the Executive on 22 September 2026 and now in committee, would tax residents' foreign dividends, interest, rents and capital gains at 15%, ending the country's long treatment of that income as outside its tax net.

The text as filed has one transitional provision. It gives the Executive six months to issue regulations. The final line reads "Rige a partir de su publicación": it applies from publication. There is no grandfathering of people who moved under the territorial rule, no step-up of cost basis for assets already held, and no start at the beginning of a tax year. Apart from an existing option for assets acquired before July 2019 to pay 2.25% of the sale price, which the text does not clearly extend to foreign assets, a gain built up over years would be taxed in full on a sale after publication, and losses on foreign assets would not count against it.

The bill may change in committee; a transitional rule is the obvious amendment. But as filed, it treats past reliance on the territorial system as irrelevant.

What the four answers have in common

They are not ranked by how high the tax is. Italy's flat tax at €300,000 is far more expensive than Costa Rica's 15%. They are ranked by how the state treats someone who acted on its earlier word.

That treatment is a policy choice, made every time, by the same governments that design the regimes. Thailand and Italy, when competing for arrivals, drew a clean line. Japan, tightening a status that is not a tax regime but a permanent permission, reached into pending files. Italy, taxing departures rather than arrivals, chose a design that leaves no window. Costa Rica, extending tax to income it had never taxed, chose none.

There is a pattern in that. States protect reliance when they want the person to come, and protect it less when the person is already there or is leaving. That is not a moral judgement. It is a description of incentives. Foreign residents rarely vote, which is one reason, explored in The Brief's essay on the fee state, why charges on them are easy to raise. The same incentive shapes transitional clauses.

How to use this

Three practical lessons follow, none of them about any single country.

Read the end of the text first. When a change is announced, the question "what is the new rule" is less urgent for someone already inside a regime than "who does it apply to, and from when". That answer is usually in the last few paragraphs.

Look at a country's record, not its brochure. A jurisdiction that has grandfathered existing users in past changes is likely to do so again; one that has not is unlikely to start. The Brief's essay on why boring jurisdictions win makes the broader case that predictability is worth more than a rate. Transitional clauses are where predictability can be measured.

Keep the evidence that a transitional clause will ask for. The generous clauses are not automatic. Thailand's protects only income that can be shown to have arisen before 2024. Italy's flat tax depends on the date residence was transferred. Exit taxes everywhere depend on cost basis and acquisition dates. People who kept records can use the protection; people who did not, often cannot.

For anyone comparing impatriate regimes in Europe or territorial countries elsewhere, the headline rate is the start of the comparison. The transitional clause of the last change, and of the one before it, says more about what the next change will look like.

Work with Sebastian

If your residence or tax position depends on a regime that could change, and you want to know which parts of it are protected and what evidence you need to keep, that is the kind of cross-border planning Sebastian works on with internationally mobile clients. Book a consultation.